4151 Merrick Rd, Massapequa, NY 11758 | Est. 1981
(516) 799-1871
Carmelas of Massapequa

Current Specials

Flat Bread

Flat Bread

Fig Flatbread (Baby arugula, mozzarella, fig jam, ricotta and prosciutto drizzled with balsamic glaze)
$ 18
Soup of the moment

Soup of the moment

Call us to find out 516-799-1871

$ 7
$ 11
We at Carmela's are extremely proud of our 40 years in business and would like to take a moment to "THANK" you, our customers, community, family and friends for your patronage and support over the years.

All of us at Carmela's would like you to accept our utmost appreciation and heartfelt THANKS for giving us the chance to serve you.
May we always make your dining experience at Carmela's a memorable one for the next 39 years.  When you put in quality, its quality you’ll find!

Weekly Specials


Baby Arugula Spring Salad 18
Baby arugula, strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, and grapes tossed in honey balsamic topped with shaved parm.

Stuffed Pepper 14
 Filled with crumbled sausage and spinach topped with fresh mozzarella in pink marinara sauce.

Fig Jam Flatbread 18
Baby Arugula, mozzarella, fig jam, ricotta and prosciutto drizzled with balsamic glaze.

Marsala Mussels 16
Tossed in mushroom marsala sauce.

Stuffed Artichoke 18
Seasoned breadcrumbs.





Stuffed Sole 32
Rolled sole filled with crabmeat, shrimp and breadcrumbs served oreganata style with roasted potato and mixed vegetables.

Veal Chop Margarita 45
Pounded and breaded veal chop topped with filetto di pomodoro sauce and fresh mozzarella, served with cavatelli pasta.

Tortellini Mama Mia 24
Large tortellini in pink cream sauce with diced shrimp, peas, and mushrooms.

Chicken Oreganata 27
Grilled chicken topped with seasoned breadcrumbs in pan gravy with peas, caramelized onions, and potato.

 Hot honey teriyaki Burger 20
Short rib and prime blend topped with spicy honey teriyaki onions, provolone and ranch. Served with french fries.

*Ask for the special dessert of the day
(All homemade with love by Daniella )


*ALL homemade by your very own Daniella*

Flourless chocolate cake
Fried cheesecake
German apple crumb
Italian cheesecake

Deez-Treats Icecream

(NEW FLAVOR)*Apple Crumb, vanilla bean ice cream and caramel. 
*Pistachio icecream with diced up flourless chocolate cake.

*Coffee with diced up flourless chocolate cake.
*Banana icecream with walnuts , reese's pieces , flourless chocolate cake.
*ALL homemade by your very own Daniella. 

What Our Customers Say

Great food and wine selection with pleasant service.

~ Manny A

Great food... great service... highly recommended for date night ;)

~ Dhruvi A S

Amazingly delicious!!! Two thumbs up!!

~ Christine Z

What a wonderful experience. I hadn't been to Carmela's in years.. Only due to the fact I moved further away.. I stopped in tonight with my girls and was in a rush. The two teenagers I was with wanted good Italian food. So of course I went here. They knew we were in a rush.. Not only were they extremely accommodating.. The dishes were superb.!!!! The girls were happy.. I was thrilled with my dish .. Thank you Carmela's for always having that family atmostphere with high quality cuisine !!

~ Eunice C

This pizzeria is one of the best! The dishes are amazing and the staff is terrific. I enjoy coming here. On my off days, 50% of the time you'll find me here for lunch. Thanks guys. Carmela's always keeps it fresh.

~ Cristian C

Join our mailing list for specials and coupons