4151 Merrick Rd, Massapequa, NY 11758 | Est. 1981
(516) 799-1871
Carmelas of Massapequa

Current Specials

Flat bread of the week

Flat bread of the week

Diced chicken cutlet, tomatoes, basil, fresh mozzarella, garlic and oil. 
$ 14
Soup of the moment

Soup of the moment

Call us to find out 516-799-1871

$ 6
$ 10
We at Carmela's are extremely proud of our 39 years in business and would like to take a moment to "THANK" you, our customers, community, family and friends for your patronage and support over the years.

All of us at Carmela's would like you to accept our utmost appreciation and heartfelt THANKS for giving us the chance to serve you.
May we always make your dining experience at Carmela's a memorable one for the next 39 years.  When you put in quality, its quality you’ll find!

Weekly Specials


Stuffed Artichoke 14
Seasoned breadcrumbs.

Mango Salad 14
Arugula, diced mango, onions, tomatoes, craisins and roasted corn in apple cider vinaigrette.

Touch of Italy Board 18
Prosciutto, soppressata, mortadella, parmigiano-reggiano, grilled artichoke and roasted peppers.

Flat Bread 14
Diced chicken cutlet, tomatoes, basil, fresh mozzarella, garlic and oil. 



Captain Carmela's Sandwich  16
Captain Crunch chicken on brioche roll with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, asiago cheese and sriracha sauce. Served with french fries.

Stuffed Sole 28
Stuffed with crabmeat and shrimp served oreganata style with mixed vegetables and potatoes. 

Veal Spiedini  24
Veal stuffed with prosciutto, mozzarella and breadcrumbs in brown sauce with mashed potatoes. 

Creamy Pesto Pasta 19
Bowtie pasta, diced shrimp and pine nuts in creamy pesto with a touch of tomato sauce.

Parmesan Crusted Chicken 21
Topped with prosciutto, roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella in lemon butter white wine sauce. Served with mixed vegetables and potatoes. 


Flourless chocolate cake
Fried cheesecake
German apple crumb
Italian cheesecake
*homemade pistachio icecream with diced up flourless chocolate cake.

*also available in coffee
* NEW Flavor ... Banana icecream with walnuts , Reese's pieces , chocolate cake.
*all homemade by your very own Daniella. 


What Our Customers Say

Have never been to massapequa and merely found this by chance. Some of THE BEST Italian food we have ever had (and we live near the Bronx with some of the best)!! The family owned and run business has the kindest, friendliest and warm people you will find! Great food, no rushing, made to feel at home. Daniella and Gabriella are amazing and I hope to see them again soon!!

~ J.G. from New Rochelle

Carmela's is the absolute best place for amazing food, atmosphere and always greeted with a warm welcome.  We've been going for years and plan on going for many more years! Love this place!

~ Denise McGrath-DeGiovanni

This pizzeria is one of the best! The dishes are amazing and the staff is terrific. I enjoy coming here. On my off days, 50% of the time you'll find me here for lunch. Thanks guys. Carmela's always keeps it fresh.

~ Cristian C

Great food and wine selection with pleasant service.

~ Manny A

This is my favorite restaurant. The food is always exceptional until was the customer service in my favorite waiter Santos is the best. I come here they treat me like family ❤

~ Angela P

Join our mailing list for specials and coupons