4151 Merrick Rd, Massapequa, NY 11758 | Est. 1981
(516) 799-1871
Carmelas of Massapequa

Current Specials

Flat bread of the week

Flat bread of the week

Crumbled sausage, hot cherry peppers, pink cream sauce and mozzarella.

$ 13
Soup of the moment

Soup of the moment

Call us to find out 516-799-1871

$ 6
$ 10
We at Carmela's are extremely proud of our 35 years in business and would like to take a moment to "THANK" you, our customers, community, family and friends for your patronage and support over the years.

All of us at Carmela's would like you to accept our utmost appreciation and heartfelt THANKS for giving us the chance to serve you.
May we always make your dining experience at Carmela's a memorable one for the next 35 years.  When you put in quality, its quality you’ll find!

Carmela's DoorDash

Weekly Specials


Zucchini Flowers  14
Stuffed with ricotta, breaded and fried served in tomato pesto sauce. 

Chic Pea Salad 13
Onions, peppers, celery and basil tossed in light vinaigrette. 

Stuffed Artichoke 13
Seasoned bread crumbs.

Zingara Flatbread 13
Crumbled sausage, hot cherry peppers, pink cream sauce and mozzarella. 



Stuffed Veal  23
Veal rolled and filled with escarole, crumbled sausage and cheese in brown marsala sauce. Served with roasted potatoes. 

Monkfish 24
Egg battered monkfish in lemon butter white wine sauce. Served over spinach and roasted potatoes. 

Chicken Semi-Fredo 20
Pounded and panko breaded chicken topped with diced fresh mozzarella, red onion, tomatoes and basil. Drizzled with olive oil and balsamic glaze. 

Fusilli Torre di Peppe 19 
String beans, vinegar peppers, and fusilli tossed with red sauce. Sprinkled with shaved reggiano cheese. 


Flourless chocolate cake
Fried cheesecake
German apple crumb
Italian cheesecake
*homemade pistachio icecream with diced up flourless chocolate cake.
*also available in coffee 
*all homemade by your very own Daniella. 

What Our Customers Say

This pizzeria is one of the best! The dishes are amazing and the staff is terrific. I enjoy coming here. On my off days, 50% of the time you'll find me here for lunch. Thanks guys. Carmela's always keeps it fresh.

~ Cristian C

Great food. Pizza was fresh, delicious, service was fast and friendly. A+++++++ zero complains here, will be coming back soon

~ Santiago R

Simply the Best! Amazing food and the most wonderful staff you could ever ask for.

~ Richie Tee

This is my favorite restaurant. The food is always exceptional until was the customer service in my favorite waiter Santos is the best. I come here they treat me like family ❤

~ Angela P

Carmela's is the absolute best place for amazing food, atmosphere and always greeted with a warm welcome.  We've been going for years and plan on going for many more years! Love this place!

~ Denise McGrath-DeGiovanni

Join our mailing list for specials and coupons